Anime Quick Information

Title: The Place Promised In Our Early Days
UK publisher: Anime Limited
Genre: Drama, Military, Romance, Sci-Fi
Studio: CoMix Wave
Type: Movie
Director: Makoto Shinkai
Year: 2004
Running Time: 1hr 30mins
Rate this anime:
Average Rating: 8.71

Martin's review

Martin scored this with 9/10. Disagree?

Makoto Shinkai is probably best-known as the man who created the short OAV Voices of a Distant Star almost single-handedly from little more than a desktop computer; his follow-up on the other hand is a feature-length effort with a full roll call of production staff in the credits. Place Promised… is a significantly more ambitious and polished production as a result, although there are at least some general themes and ideas that it shares with its predecessor: the portrayal of things like love and friendship spanning time and space being particularly familiar to fans.

Other comparisons, such as with those of Hayao Miyazaki’s work, are quite frankly inaccurate because Shinkai’s movies are so individual, so personal, that they bear little resemblance to the Studio Ghibli veteran, or anyone else in the industry for that matter. In an alternate ‘present’, Japan is divided in two across the Tsugaru Strait; an enormous white tower has been constructed on the far northern shore whose purpose is unknown. Two teenagers make a promise to build an aircraft together and fly across to the tower, taking their friend Sayuri with them. Unfortunately time and circumstances split their friendship apart as world war looms and Sayuri falls ill with a mysterious sleeping sickness.

This summary hardly does justice to a story that is simple enough on the surface but has hidden depths of meaning and makes some profound observations of adolescence and the innocent sense of optimism that it brings. As with Shinkai’s previous work this film is visually stunning to watch: he is clearly fascinated with the world around us and how it shapes our emotions, and takes every opportunity to show this to the full. The spectacular landscapes and sunsets are shown in expansive, sweeping shots complete with simulated lens flares and a truly breathtaking sense of realism; they are a marked improvement over his earlier films but also rival many of the major studios’ recent efforts.

There are one or two minor inconsistencies in the animation itself but overall it’s meticulously rendered and complimented well by the minimalist soundtrack; the plaintive and melancholic main theme, performed on a violin, is particularly memorable.

Although Shinkai has a talent for impressing the viewer visually, this film is not lacking in the characterisation either. As with Voices… and She and Her Cat, it evokes strong feelings and emotions, placing the development of the cast in the fore and the events that affect them more in the background. The causes of Sayuri’s illness and the imminent conflict are hinted at and even explained in a roundabout way but the effects on the characters’ lives and relationships are given much closer attention.

The technobabble and politics drive the underlying story along but are not essential to the main themes, which is fortunate since they sometimes complicate things and add some minor plot holes. For all the talk of parallel universes and world wars though, it is at its heart a bittersweet and wistful story of friendship, of following your dreams and holding onto the things that matter most; delivered with a strong sense of hope and a hint of loneliness.

In Summary

Place Promised… may feature some distracting plot details that you’d normally associate with hard science fiction but anyone can relate to the fundamental messages of love, loss and nostalgia that form the core of the story. From the opening credits to the soaring, tear-jerking final scene it is a unique and heartfelt piece of cinema; I’d even go as far as to say it’s a contender for the DVD release of the year.

Screenshots (click to pop out)

Review Information

Score: 9 out of 10
Review By: Martin
Date Published: Wed, 18 Oct 2006
2 responses to our review of "The Place Promised In Our Early Days"

1. Comment by CitizenGeek

Recently watched this and I must say I was disappointed, especially following the fantastic Voices of a Distant Star!

Posted on Wed, 23 Jan 2008. CitizenGeek rated "The Place Promised In Our...": 7 out of 10.

2. Comment by Maltos

I actually much preferred this to Voices of a Distant Star [even though I loved both of them].

The only thing that knocked it down from a 10 was the occaisionally confusing and vague sci-fi elements. These, however didn't make it a less enjoyable experience.

Posted on Wed, 6 Feb 2008. Maltos rated "The Place Promised In Our...": 9 out of 10.

Post your response to our review of "The Place Promised In Our Early Days"

Editorial Spotlight

Much like winter, summer is normally a weak season with a bunch of uninteresting anime to offer. This year looks different however, since there are a lot of shows here that I'm.. Read more (0 comments)
The summer season is almost here! The spring season had a lot of quality titles from a diverse range of genres. Gargantia on the Verduous Planet provided all the cool.. Read more (0 comments)
"Every child is an artist. The problem is how to remain an artist once he grows up." - Pablo Picasso As a lover of manga and anime I believe that Bakuman is a must-read.. Read more (0 comments)

Got news?

Got some news? E-mail it to news@AUKN

Recent Comments

Orgun on Laputa - Castle In The Sky

My favourite Miyazaki film, has the right mix of action and mystery and is massively entertaining plus it looks amazing especially on Blu-ray! (Read more)

chaos on Inferno Cop

Oh my, thanks for the heads up jimmy, will look into this asap. (Read more)

speedy z5 on Elemental Gelade #2

did you leave the site or something (Read more)

jimmy on Inferno Cop

Annoyed your rating meter levels off at "10", but I enjoyed the review itself. I think the strongest testament to its quality is how the... (Read more)

speedy z5 on Elemental Gelade #2

you there my last post is kinda old and you tend to respond kinda of quickly (Read more)

About Anime UK News

Anime UK News has been going since 2004, want to contact us or learn a little more about the site? Head to the about us page.